kloPIT kloPIT v1.26.2
Kalkulator Lokalnego Opodatkowania

Last updated: 2026-10-19 Maintained by community

Comparison with alternatives

There are several ways to work out PIT-38 for shares held at foreign brokers. This page compares approaches, not named products, and states where kloPIT falls short. It is not tax advice.

Comparison by approach

CriterionManual spreadsheetTax advisor or accountantBroker-provided reportsOther online calculatorskloPIT
PrivacyStays on your device if the file is local; a cloud spreadsheet is stored by its provider.You hand your statements to a third party.Data stays with the broker.Varies: check whether your statements are uploaded to a server.Runs in your browser; data is kept locally in IndexedDB and not sent to any server.
CostFree, but you pay with the time to build and maintain it.A fee set by the provider.Provided by the broker; terms depend on the broker.Varies: free or paid, depending on the tool.Free, AGPL-3.0, no signup.
FIFO and NBP ratesOnly as correct as your formulas: you handle FIFO per account and the NBP rate from the last business day before each date.Depends on the advisor's method; ask how foreign brokers are handled.Polish brokers issue PIT-8C, which covers that broker only. Foreign brokers do not issue one.Varies: check the FIFO scope and which NBP rate date is used.FIFO per ISIN and per account (art. 24 ust. 10 ustawy o PIT); NBP average rate from the last business day before the date (art. 11a ust. 1–2 ustawy o PIT).
Dividends and PIT/ZGManual: the 19% tax, the treaty cap and PIT/ZG are yours to calculate.Done by the advisor; confirm that foreign dividends are in scope.Not covered for foreign brokers: you calculate it yourself.Varies: dividends and PIT/ZG are not always supported.Foreign dividends with the credit capped at the treaty rate (art. 30a ust. 9 ustawy o PIT), PIT-38 section G and PIT/ZG per country.
Loss carry-forwardManual.Done by the advisor.A PIT-8C reports one year for one broker; earlier losses are yours to track.Varies.5-year carry-forward with the 50% annual cap (art. 9 ust. 3 ustawy o PIT) on the Prior-year losses page.
Open sourceYou can see every formula; no one else has reviewed them.Not applicable: the method is the advisor's own.Closed: you receive the result.Varies: check whether the code is public.Open source (AGPL-3.0); the calculation code is public on GitHub.

Where kloPIT falls short

  • Import covers Interactive Brokers CSV, IBI Capital PDF and Charles Schwab CSV (without dividends). Any other broker, for example Revolut, needs manual entry. Planned brokers are on the roadmap.
  • No PIT-8C import from Polish brokers, and no filing through e-Urząd Skarbowy: you copy the values into the return yourself.
  • No cryptocurrencies (sections E/F) and no monthly flat-tax fields (sections H/I).
  • kloPIT is not an official tax administration tool and gives no legal or tax advice. Check the results before you file.

Which approach fits

  • All income at a Polish broker that issues PIT-8C: the PIT-8C may already be all you need.
  • One or more foreign brokers and you can check the numbers yourself: kloPIT, since the data stays on your device and the result is free.
  • Unusual instruments, doubts about a company plan or a wish for someone to take the filing off your hands: a tax advisor. You can still use the kloPIT output as a starting point.
  • Few trades and a wish for full control: a spreadsheet, as long as you handle FIFO per account and NBP rates correctly.

Related pages

Supported brokers and features
Import formats, tax features and known limitations.