Last updated: 2026-10-19 Maintained by community
Comparison with alternatives
There are several ways to work out PIT-38 for shares held at foreign brokers. This page compares approaches, not named products, and states where kloPIT falls short. It is not tax advice.
Comparison by approach
| Criterion | Manual spreadsheet | Tax advisor or accountant | Broker-provided reports | Other online calculators | kloPIT |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Privacy | Stays on your device if the file is local; a cloud spreadsheet is stored by its provider. | You hand your statements to a third party. | Data stays with the broker. | Varies: check whether your statements are uploaded to a server. | Runs in your browser; data is kept locally in IndexedDB and not sent to any server. |
| Cost | Free, but you pay with the time to build and maintain it. | A fee set by the provider. | Provided by the broker; terms depend on the broker. | Varies: free or paid, depending on the tool. | Free, AGPL-3.0, no signup. |
| FIFO and NBP rates | Only as correct as your formulas: you handle FIFO per account and the NBP rate from the last business day before each date. | Depends on the advisor's method; ask how foreign brokers are handled. | Polish brokers issue PIT-8C, which covers that broker only. Foreign brokers do not issue one. | Varies: check the FIFO scope and which NBP rate date is used. | FIFO per ISIN and per account (art. 24 ust. 10 ustawy o PIT); NBP average rate from the last business day before the date (art. 11a ust. 1–2 ustawy o PIT). |
| Dividends and PIT/ZG | Manual: the 19% tax, the treaty cap and PIT/ZG are yours to calculate. | Done by the advisor; confirm that foreign dividends are in scope. | Not covered for foreign brokers: you calculate it yourself. | Varies: dividends and PIT/ZG are not always supported. | Foreign dividends with the credit capped at the treaty rate (art. 30a ust. 9 ustawy o PIT), PIT-38 section G and PIT/ZG per country. |
| Loss carry-forward | Manual. | Done by the advisor. | A PIT-8C reports one year for one broker; earlier losses are yours to track. | Varies. | 5-year carry-forward with the 50% annual cap (art. 9 ust. 3 ustawy o PIT) on the Prior-year losses page. |
| Open source | You can see every formula; no one else has reviewed them. | Not applicable: the method is the advisor's own. | Closed: you receive the result. | Varies: check whether the code is public. | Open source (AGPL-3.0); the calculation code is public on GitHub. |
Where kloPIT falls short
- Import covers Interactive Brokers CSV, IBI Capital PDF and Charles Schwab CSV (without dividends). Any other broker, for example Revolut, needs manual entry. Planned brokers are on the roadmap.
- No PIT-8C import from Polish brokers, and no filing through e-Urząd Skarbowy: you copy the values into the return yourself.
- No cryptocurrencies (sections E/F) and no monthly flat-tax fields (sections H/I).
- kloPIT is not an official tax administration tool and gives no legal or tax advice. Check the results before you file.
Which approach fits
- All income at a Polish broker that issues PIT-8C: the PIT-8C may already be all you need.
- One or more foreign brokers and you can check the numbers yourself: kloPIT, since the data stays on your device and the result is free.
- Unusual instruments, doubts about a company plan or a wish for someone to take the filing off your hands: a tax advisor. You can still use the kloPIT output as a starting point.
- Few trades and a wish for full control: a spreadsheet, as long as you handle FIFO per account and NBP rates correctly.
Related pages
Supported brokers and features
Import formats, tax features and known limitations.